Sunday, 10 February 2013

Mythbusters: Is walking or running better to keep dry?


1. Question -Does walking for shelter keep you drier instead of running?
Hypothesis -Walking to shelter keeps you drier than running
Experiment -Have one person run to a shelter from 50 ft and then repeat but have them walk
Analysis -Compare the 2 sets of clothes to see which is more wet
Conclusion -Walking to shelter will keep you drier than running.
2. Running in the rain will get you more wet then walking.
3.A hypothesis is not a guess because it is an opinion on what the outcome of an experiment will be.
4.Indoor
Pro: control of variables, Changes to experiment are easier
Con: May be difficult to recreate conditions needed
Outdoor
Pro: Real life conditions
Con: Control of different variables very difficult.
5. Running or walking.
6. How wet will you get.
7. Control group: Nothing changed, just a base measurement
Experimental Group: Tested on to see if hypothesis is accurate and then compared to control results.
8. Natural precipitation rates, perspiration, wind, length of course, clothes of the same consistence.
9. The experiment the meteorologists designed for their experiment was to just have one person run and one person walk outside when it was raining, then measuring the amount of water absorbed. While the Mythbusters did their experiment in a closed environment where they were able to eliminate all other variables so they could just test the one they needed.
10. This sample size should be adequate because they were very careful to eliminate all other possible variables so the outcome would only be affected the variables they wanted. While if they did increase the sample size it would help the data become much more accurate.
11.
Time
Wind
Time(s)
Initial Mass of Suit (g)
Final Mass of Suit (g)
Water Absorbed (g)
Water Absorbed Per Second (g/s)
Adam walk
No
18.28
757
785
28
1.5
Jamie walk
No
17.84
757
790
33
1.9
Adam run
No
7.06
757
799
42
6.0
Jamie run
No
6.59
757
793
36
5.5
Adam walk
Yes
17.40
757
789
32
1.8
Jamie walk
Yes
17.56
757
788
31
1.8
Adam run
Yes
6.98
757
801
44
6.3
Jamie run
Yes
6.51
757
790
33
5.1
12. Running = 38.8ml Walking = 31.0ml
13. Scatter Plot graph













14. Bar graph











15. Advantage to Scatter plot: Easier to see a correlation between points of data
Disadvantage to Scatter plot: May have difficulties finding an average
16. Advantages to Bar graph: Very easy to figure out high and low point of data
Disadvantage to Bar graph: Finer details may be missed
17. The Mythbusters concluded that walking in the rain is better than running. This conclusion disagrees with the meteorologists saying it is better to run in the rain. I think the Mythbusters are correct because in both experiments the Mythbusters were able to eliminate more variables in their experiment than the meteorologist which would mean that their data isn't as accurate as the Mythbuster's data, thus showing that walking in the rain is better then running.  



No comments:

Post a Comment